As Olivia Culpo and her husband, NFL star Christian McCaffreyprepare to celebrate Christmas differently this year — for the first time as parents — one specific gift-giving tradition will remain the same.

Speaking to PEOPLE exclusively about her involvement in Abercrombie & Fitch’s football-themed In Her Own League campaignthe model revealed what she will be giving as Christmas gifts to her husband’s San Francisco 49ers teammates’ significant others, a.k.a. her fellow WAGs.

“I always send everybody a pie, and then I’ll have to get them my Abercrombie collection, of course,” Culpo says. “I send a pecan pie every year to everybody.”

While the 33-year-old former Miss Universe said the pecan pies are “really good,” she admitted that she doesn’t “make” the baked goods herself.

“Maybe some year, someday, I’ll get there. I ship it, so I trust professionals,” Culpo said of buying the many pecan pies for her fellow WAGs.

The purchased pies will bring a little relief to the holiday season for Culpo, the host of Netflix’s upcoming food competition seriesNext Gen Chefand McCaffrey, the 29-year-old running back, who became parents this year.

In July, the couple welcomed daughter Colette Annaliseand together with their dog, Oliver Sprinklesthey’ll spend their first Christmas as a family.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

As Christmas approaches, the couple is embracing change at home.

“The idea of any clutter used to drive me insane,” Culpo wrote, in part, on

in November. “Now that I have a baby, I actually love the way a little ‘mess’ makes a room feel: joyful, lived-in, real. A warm hug that subtly says ‘come in and by the way you don’t have to be perfect.’ ”

Culpo and McCaffrey first sparked romance rumors in May 2019. The pair went on to get engaged in April 2023, and they wed in June 2024.